icon-call
Find Your Agent
Search Please enter a zip code or agent name

Shelley Hayworth

License #: A178723
5 OUT OF 5 STARS
star star star star star (106 Reviews)
Need help with an existing policy?
icon-headphonesContact My Team
You’re minutes away from the best coverage for your home, car and more.
Get A Quote Address is required !
About Shelley
Shelley Hayworth is an agent with Goosehead Insurance located in Panama City, FL. Shelley joined Goosehead because of her unwavering commitment to take care of her clients. Using cutting edge technology to shop with dozens of "A" rated insurance companies in just a few short minutes, she is able to find the right coverage at a competitive price. She takes the time to review all of the options and customizes a policy based on the unique risks and desires of each client. After finalizing an option, Shelley is backed by a service team that has the highest client loyalty rating in the industry. Request a quote from Shelley and you will quickly understand why Goosehead is one of the fastest growing distributors of home and auto insurance in the United States.
States Licensed In: FL, GA, AL
Connect
11 Harrison Avenue, Unit A
Panama City, FL 32401
Languages spoken:
English
Hours:
We’ve got you covered,
and then some.
  • Homeowners Insurance >
  • Auto Insurance >
  • Flood Insurance >
  • Renters Insurance >
  • Condo Insurance >
  • Landlord Insurance >
  • Motorcycle Insurance >
  • Boat Insurance >
  • RV Insurance >
  • Life Insurance >
You probably looked at several houses before you found the right fit; why not look at home insurance the same way? Goosehead does the looking for you, and finds the policy that fits your needs and budget, without compromising coverage.
It seems like there’s as many car insurance companies out there as there are cars. Lucky for you, Goosehead looks under the hood of all those policies to find the right coverage for you and your ride. Think of us as your roadmap to better protection and better rates.
Having the right amount of protection in case of flooding is important. That’s why our Goosehead experts will do all the research for you. We’ll compare dozens of plans and choose what’s best for your residence, and your budget.
Sure, you may not own the building. But you own what’s in it. If a fire or disaster would cause a major setback, take a close look at renters insurance. Better yet, let us do it for you. We’ve evaluated products from dozens of the most respected insurance companies to help you home in on the right policy.
From an insurance standpoint, high rises, townhomes and condos can be, well, a little different. HOAs cover some parts of the property, leaving other areas up to you. We can help you find a policy that provides the coverage you need — at rates you’ll feel right at home with.
A rental property isn’t the same as a primary residence. Without proper protection, a landlord might be personally liable for damages from accidents or other events. We can help you determine the right coverage for your rental properties and compare rental property insurance quotes so you can operate with total peace of mind.
Driving a motorcycle is all about freedom. Speaking of freedom, there’s no need for you to spend end less hours of your free time comparing insurance plans. Comparing the best motorcycle policies from the best insurance companies to get you protected the way you should be protected, at the price you deserve.
Chances are you bought a boat for a little rest and relaxation. Goosehead makes shopping for boat insurance just as relaxing. Our expert agents will shop dozens of policies and find you the right protection, at the right price, that will really float your boat.
Your RV lets you escape to the open road. And with Goosehead, you can escape the usual time commitment of buying insurance. Our expert agents do the research for you, comparing dozens of policies and choosing the right protection for you and your home on wheels, all at the price you deserve.
As the saying goes, life happens. But sometimes it happens in ways we don’t expect. For all the great times, and the more difficult times, Goosehead can be there to make sure you and your family are prepared, and protected. If something happens to you, the right coverage will ensure your family is financially secure and well taken care of in your absence.
SPECIALTY INSURANCE
Umbrella Insurance 101
Umbrella insurance goes beyond your normal limits of liability to protect you and your family in the event of a sudden and serious situation. Relatively cheap, umbrella policies can offer additional coverage for things like injuries to others, legal fees and litigation, excessive property damage, and other personal liability situations.
HOMEOWNER INSURANCE
Homeowners Insurance 101
You found a property you love, you managed to save a down payment, and you got approved by a lender. Now you need to find a homeowners insurance policy that meets your needs, but how do you know if a policy is the right one for you?
AUTO INSURANCE
Auto Insurance 101
Most states require you to carry auto insurance. But how do you know if you have enough? A basic understanding will equip you with the knowledge you need to make smarter decisions when selecting your auto insurance policy. Let’s get started! 
HOMEOWNER INSURANCE
Water Coverages Explained
Four different types of water coverage may or may not be part of your home insurance policy. Let’s look at how they could help better protect you and your family from financial burden due to various causes of water damage to your home.
Recent Reviews
Total Agency Reviews 106
star star star star star
Kathleen T., Jul, 13 2024
Service and price.
star star star star star
Jason W., Jun, 10 2024
Shelley has been amazing to work with! She is super responsive and does a great job of finding the right insurance at the best value. THANK YOU!!!
star star star star star
Aunt B., May, 23 2024
Shelley Hayworth.
star star star star star
Farah S., May, 21 2024
Shelley Hayworth was extremely helpful, patient and understanding
star star star star star
Samuel S., May, 15 2024
Shelley was very informative and helped me get a great rate.
star star star star star
Deborah L., May, 15 2024
Needing a flood insurance quote. Saved me close to $1000. Thanks
star star star star star
Karen M., May, 14 2024
Very professional, found us a great insurance policy at a very good rate.
star star star star star
Russel R., May, 09 2024
Excellent customer service, prompt, provided what I needed and requested.
star star star star star
Michael L., May, 03 2024
Great service in a timely manner and Shelley was thorough in explaining different options.
star star star star star
Suzanne T., Apr, 26 2024
very personable, quick to return calls and followup with competitive rates.
star star star star star
Lorri B., Mar, 29 2024
Very friendly service and nice individual and she found us a great price Easy to deal with
star star star star star
Lauren O., Mar, 27 2024
Shelley Hayworth is absolutely amazing at what she does and will help you anyway possible.
star star star star star
Leon B., Mar, 15 2024
Prompt and courteous service
star star star star star
Nancy L., Mar, 10 2024
Shelly was very thorough and honest. After speaking to other companies I knew I was in the Rita e.
star star star star star
Michael S., Feb, 15 2024
very professional and pleasant and knowledgeable
star star star star star
Willaim G., Feb, 08 2024
Kind and fast service
star star star star star
Timothy L., Jan, 27 2024
Professionalism, attitude, attention to detail,, and very friendly.
star star star star star
Josiah P., Nov, 26 2023
It was easy we left with the information we needed and then f we need anymore help we can easily contact them back
star star star star star
Richard F., Nov, 10 2023
prompt and friendly service
star star star star star
Michael A., Nov, 05 2023
Shelley was very helpful and responsive.
star star star star star
Thomas S., Oct, 21 2023
Shelly Hayworth was great to work with
star star star star star
Anita G., Oct, 06 2023
Shelly responded with fast quote and answered all my questions promptly. Very personable professional and got me my homeowners coverage at a reasonable rate. Easy peasy process. Will recommend my family and friends to reach out for quotes.
star star star star star
Nathan C., Sep, 20 2023
Shelley went above and beyond for a young first time home buyer. She was very patient. Answered all of my questions no matter how many I asked. Played a huge part in helping me secure my first home. Thank you Shelley
star star star star star
Joseph P., Sep, 18 2023
The company gave me prompt service. They matched my prior insurance $$ wise but with a better rate. Everyone I talked to was courteous and helpful.
star star star star star
Richard W., Sep, 14 2023
She answered all my Questions
star star star star star
Angela J., Sep, 13 2023
Shelly seems to know her stuff and responded really quickly!
star star star star star
Cheryl P., Sep, 12 2023
Shelley was easy to work with, friendly and very efficient!
star star star star star
Jessica D., Sep, 11 2023
This was a hassle free process and very good price for the year compared to other places.
star star star star star
Joshua C., Sep, 06 2023
Shelly!
star star star star star
Alexander H., Aug, 23 2023
Shelley helped me understand all of my coverage options and was able to write a policy for me that best fits my needs. She was very helpful!
star star star star star
Kathleen H., Jul, 26 2023
Shelley Hayworth is absolutely amazing! She took care of me every step of the way!
star star star star star
Melanie B., Jul, 22 2023
Shelley went over and above for me! I appreciate that type of service!
star star star star star
Stephanie D., Jul, 14 2023
Shelly was very experienced and gave me all the options that I needed in a policy to make the best decision. Thank you!
star star star star star
Steven C., Jul, 03 2023
Shelley is amazing and super helpful
star star star star star
Barbara W., Jun, 24 2023
Pleasant and rapid response
star star star star star
Lucas S., Jun, 23 2023
Shelley Hayworth’s service was great. Answered my every question, even before I’d ask some of them. Took care of everything for me after only a few minutes on the phone.
star star star star star
Troy S., Jun, 21 2023
Excellent experience.
star star star star star
Michelle L., Jun, 20 2023
Soley based on my interaction with Mrs Shelley Hayworth. Very knowledgeable and kind! Willing to help in an otherwise stressful time! Thanks so much!
star star star star star
Micheal C., Jun, 17 2023
Excellent customer service, and quick results!
star star star star star
Garrett D., Jun, 11 2023
Shelley Hayworth is absolutely amazing. I would not have been able to accomplish as much as I did without her.
star star star star star
Doreen M., Jun, 06 2023
Very helpful and quick to respond.
star star star star star
Brian I., Jun, 03 2023
Shelley was very responsive and knowledgeable.
star star star star star
Amy L., Jun, 01 2023
The kindness, compassion and amazing customer service I received 😊
star star star star star
Berneda B., May, 30 2023
Shelley Hayworth provided outstanding customer service, was very knowledgeable and made sure to cover all the areas of the coverage. She was a pleasure to work with. Everything about my experience was top grade, which in today’s world is rare.
star star star star star
Steven G., May, 30 2023
She got me a very good for my house and said for me to call her back when it's time to renew my auto insurance.
star star star star star
Janie M., May, 30 2023
Shelly was very clear about what the insurance would cover and responded to me very quickly
star star star star star
William F., May, 01 2023
Everything went well!!
star star star star star
Michelle P., Apr, 19 2023
Professional, responsive and friendly
star star star star star
Keyahnee F., Apr, 18 2023
Communication was excellent! Very thorough and caring!
star star star star star
Richard W., Apr, 10 2023
Shelley was very quick to respond and get information back to me. She took the time to explain my options and showed genuine care towards my situation
star star star star star
Jamie D., Mar, 29 2023
Very helpful and patient. She made sure everything was exactly the same as the previous policy.
star star star star star
Jeffrey U., Mar, 26 2023
Very friendly and knowledgeable on what I needed at the time and willing to help in any way they can for the future
star star star star star
David D., Mar, 22 2023
Work ethic and communication
star star star star star
Terry O., Mar, 16 2023
Efficient friendly service
star star star star star
Telinda B., Mar, 15 2023
Shelley was very friendly and personable. I enjoyed talking with her and she answered my questions
star star star star star
Hector L., Mar, 11 2023
Great and friendly service
star star star star star
Justin W., Feb, 28 2023
Shelley is extremely helpful and courteous
star star star star star
Brandy B., Feb, 25 2023
Great, friendly service
star star star star star
Craig R., Feb, 24 2023
Shelley was phenomenal and explained everything perfectly to help me understand insurance coverage.
star star star star star
Douglas S., Feb, 06 2023
Shelley has been an absolute God-send for our family. When everyone else said what we needed didn't exist, Shelley went waaay above and beyond and found exactly what we needed. Shelley is not only is she super smart, has been kind, comforting and an amazing resource for all things Port St. Joe. I could not recommend her more highly!
star star star star star
Donald R., Feb, 01 2023
Easy to work with and talk to. She knew exactly what I needed and got it for me in a timely fashion.
star star star star star
Jerry L., Jan, 29 2023
They were very helpful and everything was quick and flawless!
star star star star star
Angela G., Jan, 24 2023
Shelley was very responsive and moved quickly on getting quotes. When she said she would do something, she did it. She was proactive and since the purchase of this home is in a new area of the country for me, she explained things that I would not normally need to be aware of where I currently live. And most importantly, I felt like she wanted to work with me to be sure that I got good coverage. I didn't feel like just another policy as I'm sure would have been the case if I had contacted one of the large carriers.
star star star star star
Stephen R., Jan, 16 2023
Shelly made everything super easy and fast. I was also able to save $600.00 a year and increase my coverage.
star star star star star
Deborah L., Dec, 30 2022
Shelley Hayworth was amazing! Closing on a house is stressful, but she handled all my homeowner's insurance needs fast and easy and communicated with the mortgage company with all necessary documents. I feel she is easily accessible with a phone call, text or email. She responds almost immediately, when she can. Truly great service!
star star star star star
Cameron M., Dec, 12 2022
Customer service
star star star star star
Tonya M., Dec, 07 2022
Great service and pricing
star star star star star
Brian M., Dec, 05 2022
Shelley is the best
star star star star star
Alysia M., Dec, 02 2022
She is amazing
star star star star star
John C., Nov, 30 2022
Shelley was wonderful. She invested several hours helping me make the best decision concerning our home owners insurance. I would highly recommend her to anyone!
star star star star star
Jerome B., Nov, 03 2022
Excellent service
star star star star star
Jill O., Oct, 18 2022
Shelley is very helpful, she worked very closely with me to get the coverage we needed.

Notice of Rights to Opt Out of Sale/Sharing

The Digital Agent is under maintenance

Please defer to our insurance type form to get in touch with an agent.