icon-call
Find Your Agent
Search Please enter a zip code or agent name

Colby Seamster Jr.

License #: 1352012
4.9 OUT OF 5 STARS
star star star star star (120 Reviews)
Need help with an existing policy?
icon-headphonesContact My Team
You’re minutes away from the best coverage for your home, car and more.
Get A Quote Address is required !
About Colby
Colby Seamster Jr. is an agent with Goosehead Insurance located in Columbus,  OH. Colby  joined Goosehead because of his unwavering commitment to take care of his clients. Using cutting edge technology to shop with dozens of "A" rated insurance companies in just a few short minutes, he is able to find the right coverage at a competitive price. He takes the time to review all of the options and customizes a policy based on the unique risks and desires of each client. After finalizing an option, Colby is backed by a service team that has the highest client loyalty rating in the industry. Request a quote from Colby and you will quickly understand why Goosehead is one of the fastest growing distributors of home and auto insurance in the United States.
States Licensed In: OH, TN, SC, GA, TX, PA, MI, OR, CO
Connect
175 South 3rd Street, Suite 355
Columbus, OH 43215
Languages spoken:
English
Hours:
We’ve got you covered,
and then some.
  • Homeowners Insurance >
  • Auto Insurance >
  • Flood Insurance >
  • Renters Insurance >
  • Condo Insurance >
  • Landlord Insurance >
  • Motorcycle Insurance >
  • Boat Insurance >
  • RV Insurance >
  • Life Insurance >
You probably looked at several houses before you found the right fit; why not look at home insurance the same way? Goosehead does the looking for you, and finds the policy that fits your needs and budget, without compromising coverage.
It seems like there’s as many car insurance companies out there as there are cars. Lucky for you, Goosehead looks under the hood of all those policies to find the right coverage for you and your ride. Think of us as your roadmap to better protection and better rates.
Having the right amount of protection in case of flooding is important. That’s why our Goosehead experts will do all the research for you. We’ll compare dozens of plans and choose what’s best for your residence, and your budget.
Sure, you may not own the building. But you own what’s in it. If a fire or disaster would cause a major setback, take a close look at renters insurance. Better yet, let us do it for you. We’ve evaluated products from dozens of the most respected insurance companies to help you home in on the right policy.
From an insurance standpoint, high rises, townhomes and condos can be, well, a little different. HOAs cover some parts of the property, leaving other areas up to you. We can help you find a policy that provides the coverage you need — at rates you’ll feel right at home with.
A rental property isn’t the same as a primary residence. Without proper protection, a landlord might be personally liable for damages from accidents or other events. We can help you determine the right coverage for your rental properties and compare rental property insurance quotes so you can operate with total peace of mind.
Driving a motorcycle is all about freedom. Speaking of freedom, there’s no need for you to spend end less hours of your free time comparing insurance plans. Comparing the best motorcycle policies from the best insurance companies to get you protected the way you should be protected, at the price you deserve.
Chances are you bought a boat for a little rest and relaxation. Goosehead makes shopping for boat insurance just as relaxing. Our expert agents will shop dozens of policies and find you the right protection, at the right price, that will really float your boat.
Your RV lets you escape to the open road. And with Goosehead, you can escape the usual time commitment of buying insurance. Our expert agents do the research for you, comparing dozens of policies and choosing the right protection for you and your home on wheels, all at the price you deserve.
As the saying goes, life happens. But sometimes it happens in ways we don’t expect. For all the great times, and the more difficult times, Goosehead can be there to make sure you and your family are prepared, and protected. If something happens to you, the right coverage will ensure your family is financially secure and well taken care of in your absence.
You’ve got the best of the best.
Meet the team.
SPECIALTY INSURANCE
Umbrella Insurance 101
Umbrella insurance goes beyond your normal limits of liability to protect you and your family in the event of a sudden and serious situation. Relatively cheap, umbrella policies can offer additional coverage for things like injuries to others, legal fees and litigation, excessive property damage, and other personal liability situations.
HOMEOWNER INSURANCE
Homeowners Insurance 101
You found a property you love, you managed to save a down payment, and you got approved by a lender. Now you need to find a homeowners insurance policy that meets your needs, but how do you know if a policy is the right one for you?
AUTO INSURANCE
Auto Insurance 101
Most states require you to carry auto insurance. But how do you know if you have enough? A basic understanding will equip you with the knowledge you need to make smarter decisions when selecting your auto insurance policy. Let’s get started! 
HOMEOWNER INSURANCE
Water Coverages Explained
Four different types of water coverage may or may not be part of your home insurance policy. Let’s look at how they could help better protect you and your family from financial burden due to various causes of water damage to your home.
Recent Reviews
Total Agency Reviews 133
star star star star star
Robert S., Jul, 14 2024
He did what he said he would do and helped me get better Insurance at a better price..
star star star star star
Kayla H., Jul, 13 2024
Colby was excellent! Very thorough and informational! He walked me through every step of the process and was so friendly
star star star star star
Kay W., Jul, 11 2024
Colby is amazing! He is great at what he does and is very knowledgeable.
star star star star star
Jenna B., Jul, 09 2024
The process was easy and fast!
star star star star star
Shelby K., Jul, 05 2024
He was very helpful, super nice.
star star star star star
Cedric O., Jul, 04 2024
Colby was very friendly and made getting a policy simple and easy
star star star star star
Terisha B., Jul, 04 2024
The customer service
star star star star star
Jennifer G., Jul, 01 2024
They provided very good, competitive rates for all my insurance needs.
star star star star star
Joshua D., Jun, 26 2024
Saved money on auto insurance
star star star star star
Caleb W., Jun, 24 2024
Matt did an awesome job helping me out. Saved me little over $100 . Would 100% recommend!
star star star star star
Amber L., Jun, 22 2024
Colby was really nice and went into detail about everything. And a first time home owner it was great to have it all explained!
star star star star star
Kelly N., Jun, 17 2024
Colby was knowledgeable and helpful. He responded quickly to texts and calls.
star star star star star
Doreen D., Jun, 16 2024
Colby was very helpful in helping me with my home owners policy.
star star star star star
Erica D., Jun, 15 2024
Professionalism, honesty, passion, and just amazing service all the way around!
star star star star star
Nicholas B., Jun, 07 2024
Colby was easy to talk to and quickly got me a better rate
star star star star star
George B., Jun, 06 2024
I was assisted in a timely manner and received all of the information I needed. It was an excellent job by Colby.
star star star star star
Daevon L., May, 30 2024
Colby had great energy and made everything smooth and fast.
star star star star star
Jodi S., May, 24 2024
Very customer friendly and efficient. And saved me money!
star star star star star
Michael H., May, 23 2024
Fantastic customer service and experience combined with excellent rates!
star star star star star
Adam M., May, 18 2024
Tim was awesome friendly and ultimately saving me money on home and auto insurance
star star star star star
Michael C., May, 17 2024
Got me a lower cost with triple the coverages I had
star star star star star
Daisy A., May, 17 2024
Colby Seamster was referred by a family member and was an absolute professional! He answered every question and concern that I had. Got me great rates and I am very happy with him.
star star star star star
Elizabeth D., May, 13 2024
Colby was super nice and helpful! He's very personable and I was super satisfied with my experience!
star star star star star
Hayley B., May, 10 2024
Very responsive
star star star star star
Sara S., May, 10 2024
Colby demonstrated excellent customer service and efficient and effective solutions to my needs. Would highly recommend!
star star star star star
Ronald T., May, 10 2024
He explained things well, he could of slowed down at times but he repeated himself if we needed him to. He walked us through what we needed to do.
star star star star star
Hayley R., May, 10 2024
Great Service, very informative
star star star star star
Aaron F., May, 09 2024
He was awesome and even got us cheaper auto insurance
star star star star star
James C., May, 07 2024
Colby was quick efficient and easy to talk to. Explained the policy well.
star star star star star
Derrick J., May, 04 2024
Colby was a pleasure to deal with. He worked on my schedule and made the entire process super easy. I would totally recommend him to anyone looking for a full service experience with a human!
star star star star star
Derek F., May, 03 2024
Very personable
star star star star star
Andre D., Apr, 28 2024
Great Service
star star star star star
Madison B., Apr, 27 2024
Colby was amazing and so helpful!
star star star star star
Brittany M., Apr, 27 2024
Colby was professional, respectful, and Punctual.
star star star star star
Paige R., Apr, 26 2024
Agent was forthcoming and to the point. He answered all questions
star star star star star
Anna C., Apr, 25 2024
Very knowledgeable/ helpful and very friendly.
star star star star star
Alishe P., Apr, 18 2024
Great to talk to and easy set up! Thanks 😊
star star star star star
Brenda V., Apr, 17 2024
Nice experience, professional person
star star star star star
Mason W., Apr, 16 2024
Service was very quick and easy, and I feel like I got a good deal. Colby was helpful
star star star star star
Grant F., Apr, 16 2024
Colby reached out very quickly and was very knowledgeable.
star star star star star
Kelly K., Apr, 15 2024
He answered my questions and found a good rate for my bundle. Was a quick turnaround time and not a drawn out process
star star star star star
Tyler C., Apr, 14 2024
Colby was very professional, very fast, and helped me save money
star star star star star
Kelsie C., Apr, 10 2024
Colby was great! Very friendly and thorough, got us a great rate for our new home. We're very appreciative!
star star star star star
Alexis J., Apr, 10 2024
Colby was wonderful! Very informative and nice. He ended up helping me save some money on my auto insurance while bundling my homeowner's insurance. 10/10 would recommend!!
star star star star star
Casey M., Apr, 10 2024
Colby was very organized and efficient. He is very personable and easy to work with.
star star star star star
Vanessa F., Apr, 09 2024
Colby has been incredible to work with!
star star star star star
Stephen L., Apr, 09 2024
Professional service. They work very hard at getting a great price
star star star star star
Parker Z., Apr, 05 2024
Working with Goosehead allowed me to save money on my insurance and was an easy process.
star star star star star
Paritosh U., Apr, 05 2024
Time efficiency, great quote with More Coverage at less pricing, great user experience, potential cost savings at renewal. Definitely recommend trying Goosehead!
star star star star star
Betty S., Apr, 05 2024
Colby and Tim was extremely nice and patient helping me sign up on line
star star star star star
Daniel M., Apr, 04 2024
When I needed to find a new insurance, was a little concerned. Was with my old agency for a few years, but Colby found me a great rate, answered all my questions and made the switch easy.
star star star star star
Lisa S., Apr, 03 2024
Colby was very friendly, took into consideration of my concerns, answered my questions, and made everything quick and easy.
star star star star star
Amanda S., Apr, 01 2024
Colby did an excellent job meeting our insurance and budget needs.
star star star star star
Christina L., Mar, 23 2024
Colby was knowledgeable and kind to work with! He was great!
star star star star star
Karmon S., Mar, 22 2024
Because Colby went out of his way to make sure that this could happen he worked so hard, and was very upbeat and positive! I have already recommended him to two people
star star star star star
Jorge F., Mar, 22 2024
Quick, thorough explanation of benefits/coverage, and easy to work with. Extremely responsive to my questions. Thank you! Jorge Flores
star star star star star
Melissa C., Mar, 21 2024
Cobly was friendly and knowledgeable. He thoroughly explained the different options and answered all of our many questions.
star star star star star
Elsa A., Mar, 07 2024
Because I got good customer service
star star star star star
Braden M., Mar, 06 2024
He was overall a great person to work with!!!
star star star star star
Madison W., Mar, 05 2024
Great to work with. Very informative, finds best insurance rates, and gets to know the client on a personal level.
star star star star star
Cody F., Feb, 28 2024
I've had a wonderful experience with no issues to mention. The only reason I chose 8 and not 10 is because I would still recommend friends and family to shop around, though I'd be sure to mention my wonderful experience here.
star star star star star
Alexandreah J., Feb, 23 2024
Very friendly and helpful
star star star star star
Stephen B., Feb, 18 2024
THE CUSTOMER SERVICE AND KINDNESS AND PROFESSIONALISM AND CARE I RECEIVED FROM THE GOOSEHEAD REPRESENTATIVE WAS ABSOLUTELY AWESOME AND OUTSTANDING AND AMAZING.
star star star star star
Kevin E., Feb, 16 2024
Handled my issues quickly and easy very professional
star star star star star
Fuad F., Feb, 14 2024
Quick and easy. Explained everything clearly. Easy to communicate with.
star star star star star
Christopher E., Feb, 11 2024
Easy to understand the process and friendly service
star star star star star
Ryan S., Feb, 10 2024
Great communication with my agent and easy process to get everything signed and submitted for paperwork.
star star star star star
Elmer B., Feb, 09 2024
Colby went above and beyond to help me.
star star star star star
Amy G., Feb, 06 2024
Quick repsonse, effective results, and poise and personable
star star star star star
Ava C., Feb, 06 2024
The help that we got was amazing, Tim made sure we were taken care of and got the best deal.
star star star star star
Tony F., Feb, 02 2024
The way I was treated very respectfully
star star star star star
Jaidyn M., Jan, 27 2024
Colby is so kind and helpful, he got me a great deal
star star star star star
Scott H., Jan, 27 2024
The agent was very helpful and took the time to explain the different coverage levels and related rates.
star star star star star
Kenidi G., Jan, 25 2024
Very personable and gave me a very good offer and explained everything well
star star star star star
Ibrahim o., Jan, 24 2024
Because I'm satisfied
star star star star star
Courtney A., Jan, 24 2024
Friendly attitude and very accommodating
star star star star star
Daniel A., Jan, 24 2024
Colby was great. Very responsive over text.
star star star star star
Todd G., Jan, 23 2024
I liked speaking with Colby and look forward to further dealings with him. He was very professional but also personable.
star star star star star
Salvador C., Jan, 21 2024
Answered all my questions and provided me with the products and services I was looking for.
star star star star star
Drew H., Jan, 21 2024
very knowledgeable and friendly. helped me get auto insurance at a much lower rate than I had.
star star star star star
Alex B., Jan, 10 2024
Respect. Personality
star star star star star
Jeffery F., Jan, 09 2024
Goose head rocks there to help the customers needs. Smooth and simple.
star star star star star
Alana L., Jan, 05 2024
Everything was very simple and explained in details. Any questions were answered within a timely manner.
star star star star star
Cheyenne H., Dec, 16 2023
Colby was so helpful in making sure we were happy with our coverage!
star star star star star
Wesley M., Dec, 14 2023
Colby was punctual, detailed, responsive to questions, and was enjoyable to talk to. Easy to work with.
star star star star star
Jared L., Dec, 11 2023
Tim was very knowledgeable and thorough with his explanations of coverage options and helped me get the best plan for the best price! Very pleased!!
star star star star star
Jessica R., Dec, 11 2023
He was extremely helpful and very professional.
star star star star star
Jason M., Dec, 08 2023
Very long conversation to work out all the issues and they were fixed perfectly.
star star star star star
Raymond P., Dec, 07 2023
Colby was very knowledgeable and knew what he was doing. He got me the best insurance, got in contact with my home lender directly, made conversation while waiting for the insurance search to run, and he made clear how easy it would be to add on new insurance plans in the future. I am excited for the future with him when I am ready to switch my auto insurance.
star star star star star
Darren W., Dec, 06 2023
colby was awesome will definitely recommend
star star star star star
Brittany G., Nov, 23 2023
Quick and through
star star star star star
Seth P., Nov, 23 2023
Great efficiency, good explaining good customer service
star star star star star
Jasmine S., Nov, 18 2023
Super helpful and beginner friendly! Made the process super easy!
star star star star star
Marquita K., Nov, 09 2023
Great customer service and rates
star star star star star
Riquelma E., Nov, 09 2023
The rep was very professional and kn
star star star star star
Kathryn M., Oct, 27 2023
Excellent rates found and excellent discussion of coverage and details of policies
star star star star star
Nicholas B., Oct, 23 2023
Colby was extremely friendly and helpful
star star star star star
Sharon C., Oct, 21 2023
Good communication
star star star star star
Amy L., Oct, 19 2023
Colby was very helpful and was quick with my quote. He went over everything in detail and saved me money on my car insurance with the bundle.
star star star star star
Mayson J., Oct, 18 2023
Colby is a good dude.
star star star star star
Christa T., Oct, 14 2023
Treated me like family
star star star star star
Karalyne S., Oct, 13 2023
Colby gave excellent customer service and gave me the best rates I’ve seen for insurance. I’m excited to share this company with friends and family!
star star star star star
Amanda P., Oct, 13 2023
As a first time home owner, there are so many moving parts that can be stressful but this was the easiest step of the whole process! I was able to connect with Colby and received a line by line detail explanation of my policy all within 45 minutes. He made this process so easy for me and 10/10 would recommend!
star star star star star
Carie S., Oct, 11 2023
Great customer service!! Made the process quick and easy!
star star star star star
Barbara W., Oct, 10 2023
Very knowledgeable and helpful.
star star star star star
Jeanette N., Oct, 10 2023
Because all the knowledge that was given to me by Colby and he helped me make a better choice with my car insurance
star star star star star
Kaelyn H., Oct, 06 2023
Colby was very informative and helpful with securing me a bundled home and auto insurance with a low monthly payment.
star star star star star
Cody R., Oct, 06 2023
smooth process, Colby was friendly and easy to talk to, prices were lower for better coverage
star star star star star
Nataliandrea D., Sep, 28 2023
Colby was absolutely amazing!
star star star star star
Andrew L., Sep, 18 2023
Colby was great, easy to talk to, and found me hundreds of dollars in savings compared to my prior policies.
star star star star star
Darren H., Sep, 17 2023
Very nice to talk too, and he answer all my need and the price were nice.
star star star star star
Patricia D., Sep, 16 2023
Colby was easy to talk to, answered any question I had and and went over all the details to the agreement. Very easy to work with. Thank you, Colby.
star star star star star
Christian F., Sep, 13 2023
Colby was great to work with
star star star star star
Mikayla L., Sep, 09 2023
I was recommended Colby through the housing agent we are buying through. When looking into things such as home insurance, etc.. especially as a first time home buyer, it can be very overwhelming you feel a tad bit discouraged when hearing all of the numbers given. As soon as I spoke with Colby, everything was clear as day and I felt assured that he was going to take great care of me. Me as a person likes to know every detail, and Colby was able to provide just that. Aside from the business aspect, Colby was also extremely easy to talk to and made me feel as though I was talking to a very close friend. I would 100% recommend Colby to anyone I know that could benefit from his offerings!
star star star star star
Nancy M., Sep, 06 2023
Great service from our agent!! Quick and easy to work with

Notice of Rights to Opt Out of Sale/Sharing

The Digital Agent is under maintenance

Please defer to our insurance type form to get in touch with an agent.